With ten, count 'em,
TEN free agents pending for the Maple Leafs this summer, it's easy to assume that the club could look very different taking to the ice next season. One could compare the situation to the arch-rival Canadiens last year, who underwent one of the most drastic off-season overhauls in recent memory. However, the caliber of NHL'ers who walked away from Montreal were the core of the team at the time. The Habs let go ties with Kovalev, Koivu, and Komisarek without blinking and quickly signed a boat-load of free agents to replace them and go forward. Cammy, Gionta and Gomez were brought in to bring the skill up front, while the back end was patched up with free agents Gill, Spacek and Mara. For the Buds, the scene looks a little different.
Players who wrap up their contracts with the blue & white after this season are as follows:
Restricted Free Agents: Nik Kulemin, Jonas Gustavsson
Unrestricted Free Agents: Garnet Exelby, Mike Van Ryn, John Mitchell, Rickard Wallin, Wayne Primeau, Alexei Ponikarovsky, Lee Stempniak, Joey MacDonald
Let's start with the RFA's:
Pretty simple formula for both Gustavsson and Kulemin...
re-sign both. The Monster has only a year in the league at a manageable salary. For him to ask for a raise would be a major surprise and at the current going rate of 2.5 million, he should be extended for at least a year or two. For Kulemin, a raise could be in order but not anything substantial. Kuli's cap hit right now is about 1.5 million per season. I would expect him to be extended at about 1.8-1.9 million. He is an excellent defensive forward and it seems like Wilson is a pretty big fan of his. This could be a player that in two years turns out to be a real gem, and it would be a very nice tribute to Wilson for him to become a solid NHL'er exclusively under his coaching. Keep them both for at least another 2 years, it's a no-brainer.
Now, on to the UFA's :
Exelby - Will be shopped at the deadline for ANY type of return. Likely will not see free agency. If he does? Let him go. It sounds harsh, but he was only brought in because the trade took Kubina's 5 mill off the books.
Van Ryn - Finally, his salary will be off the books this summer. The once promising, but oft-injured d-man came over in the trade when Toronto fans ran Brian McCabe out of town a couple seasons ago. Van Ryn is an excellent play with pure hockey sense, but known by most Leafs fans as the guy who got put through the glass by Lucic in Boston. It's a shame that injuries ruined his career. Can anyone believe that the LEAFS gave up an ADDITIONAL PICK to Florida in that swap? Hopefully he gets healthy and another team gives him a chance and he can revive his career. I don't think Van Ryn will ever play another game in a Leafs uni.
Mitchell - Not sure if he's being shopped for a deadline deal. If so, expect a late round pick (5th or 6th round). If Mitchell gets to free agency in the summer, he could be re-signed but I wouldn't bank on it. JM only makes half a million dollars, so expect him to want a raise that he doesn't deserve. Personally, I'd let him walk. Too inconsistent.
Primeau - At his current rate of 1.4 million he should be extended for a year or two. I doubt he'll be looking for much of a raise. Primeau is a solid two way forward who can forecheck, lay the body and pot the occasional tally. If the Buds let him go, they'll only try to sign another guy to fill his role. It's just as well to keep him because he plays his game very well.
Wallin - is a poor man's Wayne Primeau. Love him or hate him, Wallin plays the defensive game well. Only problem is, that's absolutely ALL THAT HE DOES. With Primeau you get a great defensive center with a major physical upside. With Wallin, you get a defensive center and that's all. There's no need to keep both. As Bozak and Hanson move down the depth chart at center (if the Leafs manage to grab a top line elite center, which should be a priority), Wallin should be pushed out and Primeau
should keep his spot on the fourth line.
Ponikarovsky - Easily the most sought after Maple Leaf this season. Expect to see him in another jersey before the end of the season. Most likely headed to Pittsburgh, Montreal or Atlanta. I'd put Nashville and Chicago as long shots. The Penguins could definitely use his size and 25-30 goal output. He's a solid scoring winger and should bring in at least a second round pick, which is apparently the minimum asking price for #23. If he stays until the summer (very, very unlikely), expect him to want a raise. Poni will likely yield in the ball park of 4 million per season, around the same as his buddy Nik Antropov grabbed in free agency last summer. He'll be a good second line winger on any team going forward, Leafs included.
Stempniak - Probably won't have much of a return in the trade market going into March 3rd. If anything, maybe a 4th or 5th rounder coming back, but very doubtful. His cap hit of 2.5 mill is not really something any team is looking for. The only way Stempy stays in TO is with a pay cut, which is quite unlikely but not impossible. Expect him to walk in the summer.
MacDonald - Third in the goalie depth chart. Will continue to play for the Marlies and emergency call ups with the big club. Easily affordable. Likely staying around.
There's no question that the Leafs will look very different next year, especially with names like Kadri and Stefanovich in the prospect pool. The question is, what will Brian Burke add to the club to really get them over the top and in to Cup contention?
-MSU